This year, following the NWSL playoffs has also meant becoming an expert on grass maintenance and on event scheduling at soccer-specific stadiums.
Both NWSL semifinals, beginning with today's match between the Washington Spirit and Utah Royals, were besieged by complications that had nothing to do with the actual teams trying to play at their usual home venues.
Two of the semifinalists, the Spirit plus I-95 rivals Gotham FC, faced major issues pertaining to their home fields, Audi Field in DC and Sports Illustrated Stadium in Harrison, New Jersey.
The Spirit were on the verge of having to move their semifinal to the Washington Commanders' NFL-sized (60,000 capacity) stadium in Landover, Maryland, due to a scheduling conflict with a Division III NCAAA football game, the Secretaries' Cup, but instead are playing an awkwardly-timed doubleheader with that same American football game.
Gotham, meanwhile, is hosting Kansas City Current at the 5,000-seat Icahn Stadium on Randall's Island, not because of a scheduling conflict — though there is a scheduling conflict involved in their kerfuffle, too — but because the pitch at Sports Illustrated Stadium is in dire shape, branded as extremely subpar by players and coaches from both teams after Gotham's quarterfinal win over Seattle Reign FC last weekend.
Rather than risk the quality of the playing surface in New Jersey causing injury or impacting the play of either team, Gotham chose to downsize on Randall's Island, where the grass is greener but the venue is tiny and tricky to reach. The Red Bulls shared a statement about the Gotham field situation after the relocation was confirmed, saying in part, "We worked closely with Gotham and the NWSL to address their concerns, but unfortunately the experts and the league couldn’t guarantee the additional work they wanted to be completed could be done in time."
These are the two biggest games of the NWSL playoffs that aren't the actual NWSL Championship game, and both are getting overshadowed by extracurricular developments that are entirely out of the control of both of the higher-seeded home NWSL semifinalists.
Both Gotham and Spirit are at the mercy of decisions and management by Major League Soccer organizations that operate their usual home stadiums. Audi Field is under the control of DC United, while Sports Illustrated Stadium is operated by Red Bull GmbH, parent company of Red Bull New York.
In both instances, decisions made by stadium operators proved costly for the NWSL teams that act as tenants in each stadium. The Spirit will play Utah with American football lines and markings painted all over the Audi Field pitch, and they are being unceremoniously rushed out of the stadium, as their 12:30 pm ET kickoff against Utah Royals is being followed immediately by that Secretaries' Cup football game, which is slated to begin at 4:30 pm ET, a delay from the original 1:00 pm ET start time for football.
ARE YOU READY FOR SOME FOOTBALL 🥴🥴
— Hey Spirits! (@heyspirits.bsky.social) November 14, 2026 at 11:02 AM
[image or embed]
Gotham faced an even worse situation in New Jersey, as the playing surface at Sports Illustrated Stadium deteriorated badly late in the MLS and NWSL seasons. Gotham got fined $10,000 for the state of the pitch on NWSL Decision Day on November 1, then it only got worse for the playoffs to the point where Gotham coach Juan Carlos Amorós apologized for the state of it to his opposition from Seattle. All the quotes that emerged post-Gotham/Seattle made it seem like the game suffered from the brown, sandy, low-quality pitch.
Complicating factors for the pitch in Harrison, NJ: A rugby doubleheader got played there on Friday, October 30, further tearing up the grass beyond the damage done by the stadium's usual soccer load. Gotham played there two nights later, the game that got them fined.
The Red Bulls, meanwhile, also had a postseason friendly scheduled with Club América of Mexico's Liga MX for the night of Saturday, November 14, meaning any repairs or interventions made to the field on Gotham's behalf to make it playable for the semifinal would still have needed to survive 90 extra minutes of soccer before Gotham hosted its semifinal on Sunday, November 15.
The field in New Jersey couldn't be brought up to snuff for Gotham or the NWSL, despite lots of talk and potential planning around repairing it. Icahn Stadium's field, inside the running track since a $3 million installation paid for by New York City FC in 2024, should be in good shape for the semifinal, but the small venue is incongruous with a NWSL match of this magnitude.

Semifinal tickets a the 5,000-seat stadium that were made available to the general public sold out in a matter of minutes. All seats are general admission, with a single small concession stand and set of restrooms to serve the one stand. Gotham is arranging free shuttle buses and ferry rides to get ticketed fans onto and off Randall's Island for the match, the third time Gotham hosts at Icahn in the third different competition: Concacaf W Champions Cup, NWSL regular season, and now NWSL playoffs.
Some number of Gotham fans have spoken longingly of a day when this kind of thing won't happen: When the club moves into its new home in New York City, Etihad Park in Queens, for the 2028 season.
Etihad Park has ambitions identical to Audi Field and Sports Illustrated Stadium, being a place to host lots of extra, non-New York City FC/Gotham FC events to fill out a fuller, more profitable annual calendar than just what MLS and NWSL offer.
While Gotham has been referred to as being "more than a tenant" at Etihad Park by NYCFC president and CEO Brad Sims, it's still a task in front of the powers that will be booking the calendar in Queens in 2028 to avoid a similarly nightmarish sequence of events occurring once the stadium expands its offerings.
The financially-motivated desire to host as many major events as possible at your soccer-specific stadium, soccer or otherwise, can come with serious side effects when they disrupt the seasons of any of the consistent users of the stadium. If ever there was a chance to learn from the example set by others, these recent weeks at Audi Field and Sports Illustrated Stadium provide it.
Throwing a rugby doubleheader onto a pitch in Harrison that had gotten heavy and steady use for soccer since being re-sodded following World Cup fan fests in late-July, and then giving that pitch almost no time to recover before it hosted Gotham's final regular season match, should have been a bigger call to action.
It resulted in that $10,000 fine handed down by NWSL, but the surface didn't get much better between that weekend and the following, when RBNY closed out its season against Atlanta United FC on November 7, the night before Gotham hosted the Reign on the afternoon of November 8, when the quality of the surface became the main talking point.
Etihad Park is definitely planning to host the exact kinds of extra events that have thrown wrenches into the NWSL's semifinal plans. Rugby and lots of extra soccer matches — friendlies, international competitions, etc. — have been mentioned directly. The juggling act for the playing surface has to be navigated more smoothly if life at Etihad Park is going to avoid this kind of situation recurring for Gotham.
"Obviously we, first and foremost, want to be the cathedral of soccer, men's soccer, women's soccer, national team soccer, friendlies, international competitions," Sims said in an August 2026 group interview. Beyond soccer, though, Sims said, "...We're working on concerts. We think rugby and lacrosse are two sports that the field dimensions work well for, that have some potential as well."

While discussing an agreement with the New York Mets over Etihad Park attendee use of Citi Field's parking lots, NYCFC's CEO mentioned that they have the ability to host up to 45 "major events" per year, though with an added aside that they hope to potentially host more in the future. "The way it's set up now is that we have up to 45 major event dates there, which would be inclusive of New York City FC, Gotham, and other major events that the Mets have agreed to provide parking for."
Regular-season home matches for Gotham and NYCFC would account for 32 of those dates right off the bat, though each club has potential to host more than that given the various cup competitions in which they compete. There will be extra events. Making sure the field doesn't get overbooked or outright destroyed, and at the expense of one of the stadium's home teams, should be a requirement in Queens.
It might be that the relationship between NYCFC and Gotham, as they share Etihad Park, will be better and run smoother than what Gotham had in New Jersey with the Red Bull organization.
Sims, CEO of NYCFC, said in that August interview that with Gotham and NYCFC, "We're set up in a less traditional structure, it's not just a straight landlord-tenant relationship where the tenant pays rent and then they lease out the building, like what we have now, or what maybe they have now. We wanted this to be, from the beginning, a tighter relationship. The way we, Etihad Park and New York City FC, benefit is more by them being successful, the more successful they are, the more financially beneficial it is to NYCFC. We have skin in the game."
That might mean there's no risk of a repeat for Gotham once they've changed home venues, but Etihad Park aspires to run in a similar fashion to two nearby soccer stadiums that have run into issues while hosting two soccer tenants plus lots of other things, so the risk will still be there, until Gotham can follow Kansas City Current's path and get its own stadium with no cohabitants.

