Skip to content

Icahn't Believe It: Gotham falls to Current in NWSL Semifinal

Struggles in attack and a pair of set-piece goals from Kansas City ended Gotham's season at Icahn Stadium, with the Shield winners and defending NWSL champions falling just short of a return to the championship game.

Photo courtesy of Gotham FC.

Gotham FC could not escape their attacking struggles, and those finally caught up to the NWSL Shield winners in Sunday's NWSL Semifinal match at Icahn Stadium on Randall's Island.

The Kansas City Current advanced to the 2026 NWSL Championship match next weekend, getting past the home side, 2-1, buoyed by two goals scored from dead-ball situations.

In total, Gotham played 180 minutes of playoff soccer in 2026. In that time, the league's top regular-season team and reigning NWSL Championship winners registered zero shots on goal. Two own goals, one last week to beat Seattle Reign FC and one against Kansas City, were the only offense Gotham could manage this postseason.

Gotham was seeking a third trip to the NWSL Championship in four years, and trying to repeat as champions. Instead, the Current will play in their first championship match since 2022 against the Washington Spirit next Saturday night, November 21, at Audi Field in Washington, DC.

This was a game marked for spectacle before it kicked off at 3:20 PM local time, delayed by college basketball running long on ABC, the broadcast home of the match. Gotham's ongoing strife with its current home venue of Sports Illustrated Stadium was the talking point since Gotham's win over the Reign ended there last Sunday.

The possibility of Gotham being pushed out for an international friendly between playoff-eliminated Red Bull New York and Liga MX side Club América was avoided. However, the new issue of field conditions, which previously resulted in Gotham being assessed a $10,000 fine by the NWSL for the state of the pitch, forced a change to the much smaller, 5,000-seat Icahn Stadium in New York City proper.

The Current weren't without their own issues. The fourth seed in the playoffs planned to fly via charter flight on Friday, but were grounded along with the entire nation during the hours-long FAA ground stop. The team instead held a morning training session in Kansas City on Saturday, and flew out later that afternoon, arriving in NYC on Saturday night.

In the end, both team's off-field issues played little into the result. Gotham played the same high press but no bite soccer they've played since rookie Jordynn Dudley went down with a foot fracture last month. Kansas City got a free-kick goal from Croix Bethune in the first half, then a late winner from Haley Hopkins that also came from a free kick.

GAME STATS

Gotham FC: 0.49 xG, 6 shots, 0 shot on target, 65% possession, 444 passes, 83% pass accuracy, 14 fouls, 3 corners, 1 saves

KC Current: 0.92 xG, 11 shots, 3 shots on target, 35% possession, 205 passes, 70% pass accuracy, 19 fouls, 6 corners, 1 save

Goals:
• KC Current, Croix Bethune, 20'
• Gotham, Laney Rouse (own goal), 69'
• KC Current, Haley Hopkins, 89'

Attendance: 4,698

Gotham's attacking struggles continue

In the shadow of the Triborough Bridge, Gotham never looked set. The Current came out in a 4-2-3-1 formation and played high-press, offense-heavy soccer. Something that first year head coach and New York area native Chris Armas has implemented all season. Despite only having 32% of possession in the first half, the visitors played far more with the ball.

A poor, possibly slightly deflected, clearance by Gotham's Guro Reiten in the 15th minute gave KC their first major chance. The ball settled near midfield, where Michelle Cooper played around Gotham players as she made her way up the right, playing a long ball toward Temwa Chawinga. Her shot under pressure from the right side got past Gotham's star keeper Ann-Katrin Berger, but slipped just wide left of the goal.

A few minutes later, Gotham midfielder Denise O'Sullivan pushed attacking midfielder Croix Bethune from behind about 12 yards out from the center of the penalty area. Bethune then scored probably one of the nicest looking direct free kick goals in the NWSL this season.

0:00
/0:19

Croix Bethune scores Kansas City's first goal with the team's first shot on goal | Credit: NWSL

The NWSL record holder in single-season assists, set this season, curved the ball to the left around the standing Gotham wall. The wall turned back, and the ball settled into the lower left corner of the net, beyond a diving Berger.

Despite looking into the setting sun over the East River, Gotham's defense looked stunned by the strike, trailing for the first time in these playoffs.

Follow @nysoccerjournal.com on Bluesky for this kind of photography.

Own Goal helps Gotham again

Gotham entered halftime still without a shot, and still needing momentum. Head coach Juan Carlos Amorós looked to change both of those by bringing on Rose Lavelle for O'Sullivan.

With four goals this season, Lavelle was tied for third-most on the team, though she'd gone without a goal since mid-July and dealt with injuries late in the season, questionable for this game and only available for the final 45 minutes.

Gotham had withstood the pressure of the Current for the most part, but now, offense needed to kick up. A free kick off the rip in the 47th minute after Lavelle was fouled gave some hope, though the chaos in the box did not result in a shot for Gotham. Another free kick in the 52nd, this time on the left near the end line, was sent in by Jaedyn Shaw and redirected wide right of the post by Midge Purce.

The offense was starting to click, but it was the Current who'd technically strike next. Purce went on a run along the right side of the field in the 69th minute, playing the ball into the box. KC defender Gabrielle Robinson and keeper Lorena Leite both went for it, with the ball hitting off the goalkeeper and toward defender Laney Rouse. She tried to play the ball, but accidentally sent it painfully, slowly over her own line to make it 1-1.

0:00
/0:09

Own Goal comes up big for Gotham for a second straight game | Credit: NWSL

For the moment, Gotham had the momentum for the first time all day. Gotham started to play forward more as Purce, Lavelle, and Kerr all started to see more of the ball in the opposing end trying to make the most of the team's 60% possession in the second half.

Hopkins puts it away

The final 20 minutes slowly saw the game fall back into the Current's lap. Corner kicks, set-pieces, fouls and the like all played into the visitor's hands as they started to keep the ball firmly in the north end of the stadium.

One of those corner kicks in the 82nd nearly ended the match right then and there, as the ball in the box fell to Current captain Lo'eau LaBonta who slammed a shot off the right post of goal.

Between those posts was Berger, one of the finalists for NWSL Goalkeeper of the Year, who continued to make the types of saves that got her on that shortlist. That included a jumping punch of a Temwa Chawinga shot attempt in the 87th minute.

In the 88th minute, Gotham fullback Guro Reiten was called for a handball about 10 yards from the box, giving Izzy Rodriguez the opportunity to send a well-placed ball toward the back post. Arriving there was striker Haley Hopkins, who brought down the ball before sending it above Burger's jump, off the crossbar, and down into the net.

0:00
/0:09

Haley Hopkins calls ballgame | Credit: NWSL

Both goals for the Current came off set pieces, the perfect way to score on a team when you don't control the ball for a majority of the time.

Gotham attempted a last-minute counter attack before the three minutes added onto the 90 were up, but their efforts fell short, ending the 2026 season just short of the NWSL Championship match.

Comments

Latest