Skip to content

How the New York City FC depth chart looks as the offseason begins

Checking in on the needs, strengths, and weaknesses of the current New York City FC squad after sporting director Todd Dunivant parted with eight members of the 2026 roster to kick off a critical offseason rebuild.

These guys won't be training again for a bit. Photo: newyorkcityfc.com

Contract decisions have been made, farewells have been said by the club and the departing players, and New York City FC is now in Offseason Mode while operating with a much-changed squad after missing the playoffs and laboring through a down year.

There's a coaching vacancy, first and foremost, and filling it is likely the current top priority in front of NYCFC sporting director Todd Dunivant. Dunivant already made some big decisions on the roster side, though, parting ways with eight members of his 2026 MLS squad while exercising contract options to retain three players through the 2027 season.

NYCFC begins the offseason with 27 players signed to first-team contracts, though three of those 27 — forwards Julián Fernández, Jovan Mijatović, and Seymour Reid — are away from the team while on loan with other clubs. There could also still be more outgoing player moves to come, with rumors connecting multiple members of the NYCFC roster with possible departures earlier this summer.

New York City FC Tracker: All 2026 news and rumors
NYCFC today shared all its end-of-season roster decisions, with Thiago Martins and Keaton Parks confirmed to be leaving, along with players like Mitja Ilenič and Matt Miazga.

The transfer market has plenty of time to gain more steam, with the sprint season not kicking off until February 20, 2027, but here in November 2026, it's worth taking a moment to look at how the NYCFC roster stacks up as currently constituted.

First, there's the big-picture depth chart, with all 24 players distributed across a hypothetical 4-2-3-1 lineup. Note, we're not including any of the loaned-out guys in this exercise, and we're sticking with the 4-2-3-1 for now, because there's no way of knowing how the unknown next head coach of NYCFC will want to line his team up.

Look through the depth chart as it stands below, then read on for a walk through each position group on the roster — goalkeepers, defenders, midfielders, and forwards — written with an eye towards identifying the biggest areas of need that Dunivant will have to address this offseason. I didn't include each player's roster designation, meaning if they are a Designated Player, TAM player, Homegrown player, or member of the senior or supplemental roster, but you can find those details in this post written back in September, and some of those mechanics get touched on at the very bottom after going through each position group.

November 2026 NYCFC depth chart
24 players, 4-2-3-1 formation


Goalkeepers (3)

Matt Freese, Tomás Romero, Greg Ranjitsingh

There's very little uncertainty in goal, so long as Matt Freese doesn't get sold to a European club this winter. Freese remains one of the better goalkeepers in MLS despite all the negative attention he drew from the summer World Cup onward, while Romero and Ranjitsingh just signed contract extensions that keep them in the fold through the end of the 2027/28 season. Freese is signed through 2030, but he already holds a European passport (making an international transfer simpler), and he's been mentioned repeatedly in the rumor mill since breaking out with NYCFC in 2024 and ascending to the top of the United States men's national team goalkeeper ranks. If Freese leaves, the position would be thrown into much more uncertainty, given Romero has looked shaky in his few opportunities to serve as a starter at MLS level.

This post is for subscribers only

Subscribe

Already have an account? Sign In

Latest

NYCFC attendance rose slightly during the 2026 season

NYCFC attendance rose slightly during the 2026 season

Year-over-year home attendance increased by 3.6% for New York City FC in 2026, buoyed by the second-biggest home crowd in club history turning out to see Lionel Messi in March, with 2026 representing NYCFC's best overall and average attendance numbers since the 2018 season.

Members Public