Skip to content

Liberty City Revisited: What 13 years have been like for New York soccer

With Grand Theft Auto VI's release closing a 13-year gap between GTA games, we compare the local pro soccer landscape of 2013 to what we see today.

Photo via Getty Images

If you are reading this article, you might be taking a break from playing Grand Theft Auto VI.

Maybe you are checking reviews, maybe the Xbox or Playstation networks are fried, maybe your boss is calling you saying he sees you online and accusing you of being a liar for taking off work for being sick.

In any case, it has been 13 years between Grand Theft Auto releases. Grand Theft Auto V officially launched on September 17, 2013, and now Grand Theft Auto VI is here today November 19, 2026, a phenomenon that has people planning their four-day weekends and has the New York City Board of Education reminding students that school is still open, even if GTA VI is now available.

The nostalgia hit of a new GTA game releasing has given plenty of people a chance to look back at where they were in 2013 and where they are now, including New York City FC.

What better way to have fun on the release day of one of the biggest entertainment properties of all time than to follow this trend, but through the lens of local professional soccer? Let's take a look at four of the major New York-area soccer teams and see what the jump from the Xbox 360 to the PlayStation 5 has been like for each of them.


New York Cosmos

2013: First season back from the dead, NASL championship
2026: First season back from the dead, USL League One Wooden Spoon runners-up

History doesn't repeat, but it sure does rhyme.

After first re-emerging in 2010, the New York Cosmos officially returned to professional soccer in 2013. The team joined the second iteration of the North American Soccer League in mid-2012, and began poaching local soccerheads.

Former New York Red Bulls managing director Erik Stover, the man who helped get Red Bull Arena finished and helped bring Thierry Henry to Harrison, NJ, was made chief operating officer. Former NY/NJ MetroStars legend Giovanni Savarese was confirmed as the team's first head coach. Former Red Bulls defender Carlos Mendes, a native of Long Island, became the team's first player signing.

They launched with a bang, too. After sitting out the 2013 NASL Spring Season, the team's first match back on August 3, 2013, was a dramatic 2-1 win over the Fort Lauderdale Strikers in front of over 11,000 fans at Shuart Stadium. Alessandro Noselli scored the game winner in stoppage time in a game that was delayed a few minutes for the return of international superstar and Cosmos legend, Pelé, who welcomed the fans in Hempstead to the next generation of the team.

The Cosmos went on to finish first in the NASL Fall Season, qualifying for the 2013 Soccer Bowl, where they beat the Atlanta Silverbacks. Former Villarreal CF forward Marcos Senna scored the lone goal.

Fast forward to today, and the Cosmos are once again back from the dead. Though the team is definitely less shiny and lacking the name-brand appeal of the 2013 version.

The 2010s-era team went on to find more success in the NASL, including signing former Spain national team player Raul and knocking off both local New York-area MLS teams in the US Open Cup, but the SoccerWarz eventually caught up with the Cosmos.

They ceased operations in January 2021 following league chaos and team instability. But, somehow, the Cosmos returned. A press conference in July 2025 marked the occasion officially, with a new trio at the top. New majority owner Baye Adofo-Wilson, returning team executive Erik Stover as CEO, and former Italian international and local star in his playing days, Giuseppe Rossi, as vice chairman and director of soccer.

The message was clear: This was not going to be the same Cosmos. Less flashy player signings and a focus on developing local talent was the announced goal.

Well, they nailed one thing: This was not the same Cosmos. After an impressive showing in the team's first home match in Paterson's Hinchliffe Stadium, drawing 4,099 fans for what would be a 3-1 loss to Portland Hearts of Pine, things fell apart quickly. The Cosmos struggled to find consistency, only winning three of 18 games between March and July. The crowds shrunk, officially averaging 1,497 a game, but usually only having a few hundred fans actually in the stadium.

There were some bright spots. Ajmeer Spengler emerged as a top attacking midfielder, scoring 11 goals in his third professional season, a personal best. Team captain and returning Cosmos legend Sebastián Guenzatti followed with 10 goals, as the 35-year-old still showed consistency in the lower divisions of US soccer.

However, the Cosmos are no longer a flashy team. In 13 years, they've gone from a sexy non-MLS alternative to an afterthought. It will be a large undertaking to correct the club's faults.

Gotham FC (fka Sky Blue FC)

2013: New league, semifinal loss
2026: First Shield, semifinal loss

It's insane to think how far the biggest professional women's team in the New York metro has come in 13 years. From half selling out a 5,000-seat college stadium in Piscataway, NJ, for a season opener, to nearly selling out a 5,000-seat multi-use stadium on Randall's Island for a playoff game.

Jokes aside, the transition from Sky Blue FC to Gotham FC has been phenomenal.

In 2013, Sky Blue and seven other teams helped launch the National Women's Soccer League. After three seasons in the Women's Professional Soccer (WPS) league, including a championship in 2009, it was time for yet another new beginning at Sky Blue's familiar home of Yurcak Field on the campus of Rutgers University.

The team did fairly well to start, finishing the inaugural NWSL season fourth in the league and qualifying for the playoffs. Mónica Ocampo led the team with eight goals and a 24-year-old Kelley O'Hara played her first of what would be seven seasons with the team over the course of a decade. The Blues lost to Western New York Flash in the 2013 NWSL semifinals, 2-0, downed by a brace from someone named Carli Lloyd.

Fast forward to today, and things have changed a lot. The years at Yurcak saw increased attendance, new owners, but the team's facilities drew derision, and the team struggled on the field.

A rebrand to Gotham FC and a new, then-beloved home stadium in Red Bull Arena/Sports Illustrated Stadium set a higher bar for the franchise.

Gotham is now one of the NWSL's top teams in terms of on-field success, having won a trophy in three of the last four seasons, including two league championships and a CONCACAF W Champions Cup. As a business, Gotham is just drew in a new round of $100 million in investment, meaning Forbes now estimates the Gotham franchise to be worth $350 million.

The most recent Gotham season was the best in team history on multiple fronts. A best-ever record with 18 wins and a first-ever NWSL Shield. The highest average attendance in team history by a longshot, 11,277, with a major match played at Citi Field in front of over 45,000 fans, and with a permanent move to Queens and the new Etihad Park on the horizon for the 2028 season.

Young star Jaedyn Shaw led the team in goals with 11, Ann-Katrin Berger held 12 clean sheets — enough to lead the league with the lowest Goals Against Average (0.86) and earn NWSL Goalkeeper of the Year — and amidst venue drama, the team once again reached the NWSL semifinals. A loss to the Kansas City Current curbed any hopes for a title repeat.

In total, the women's soccer team once playing with broken bathroom facilities is now a fixture of national television broadcasts on ABC. They've gone from being owned by the Governor of New Jersey to being promoted heavily by the popular Mayor of New York City. Gotham has found a successful blueprint, if you will.

New York City FC

2013: A stadium gets promised
2026: A stadium gets built

At one point in time, the Cosmos were in consideration to be the 20th team in Major League Soccer. Instead, MLS went international.

13 years ago, New York City FC was born. Manchester City, in association with the New York Yankees, paid a $100 million expansion fee to join the league.

On May 21, 2013, it was official with a press release and press conference featuring New York Yankees president Randy Levine, MLS commissioner Don Garber, and Manchester City FC CEO Ferran Soriano.

Tucked away in that press release, seven paragraphs down, sat what would become an infamous promise:

New York City FC is committed to seeking a new permanent stadium in New York. Until that time, the new team is arranging to play in an interim home beginning in its inaugural MLS season in 2015. Over the past year, MLS began discussions with the City of New York and other stakeholders about the possibility of constructing a new stadium in Flushing Meadows Corona Park (FMCP) in Queens. The Club's new management will continue these discussions with local government officials, community residents and businesses, soccer leagues, and MLS. The Club will continue to review other potential sites as well.

Now in 2026, the interim home that's been present since the team's inaugural 2015 season is about to host its last MLS matches. Yankee Stadium is getting a farewell tour as New York City FC's home venue during the 2027 Sprint Season. After years of government maneuvring, fallen-through promises, and the hopes of fans going up and down like elevators, Etihad Park in Queens is set to finally open its doors next July.

It will welcome a team that's grown a lot since that initial 2013 press release. NYCFC grew past the expansion-team growing pains of its first few seasons and became one of the toughest squads in MLS from the late-2010s through the early-2020s, winning MLS Cup and Campeones Cup and perennially making the playoffs.

The club navigated the weirdness of playing the bulk of its home matches on a converted baseball field, and also rode the wave of having to relocate numerous home games due to venue availability or suitability issues, with New York City FC ultimately playing home games at seven different venues (eight if you count the ESPN Wide World of Sports Complex from the 2020 MLS Is Back tournament) across their 12 seasons. That includes once hosting in Los Angeles, California (a six-hour flight), twice in East Hartford, Connecticut (a two-hour drive), and 20 times at the New Jersey-based stadium of their rivals Red Bull New York.

Now, the days of stadium tenancy are numbered, and there's only a few months to go until the team's long-promised stadium opens. In the end, after the stadium issues, it's not like Manchester City ever got into any other shenanigans ever again.

Red Bull New York

2013: Shield win, Red Bull Great!
2026: Back-to-back missed playoffs, Red Bull Out!

Unlike the other teams on this list, everyone's favorite MLS originals have actually been around for the entirety of the Grand Theft Auto franchise's existence. Heck, in 2008 when GTA IV released, the most recent edition set in GTA's New York City stand-in of Liberty City, Red Bull New York (or the artist formerly known as the New York Red Bulls) reached the MLS Cup Final for the first time, as Western Conference champions to boot. Also, GTA IV is one of the greatest video games of all time, but I digress.

They lost that 2008 final, and wouldn't win any major silverware until, you guessed it, the 2013 season. It was a flashy squad led by first-year head coach and team legend Mike Petke, paced by Thierry Henry and Tim Cahill's goals and a spine that featured Dax McCarty and Luis Robles, one that went on to win the Supporters' Shield with 17 wins and 59 points.

Two more Shields would follow in 2015 and 2018, but here in 2026, Red Bull is now pursuing a new endeavor. Gone are the days of flashy superstars like Henry and the brand-new stadium, in is a mantra of youth development, and of maximizing the luxury seating available in what's now a two-decade-old arena.

Red Bull has always been at the forefront of youth development in the United States since it bought the MetroStars in 2006, and now they've fully embraced the youth development model as a first team pillar. It's similar to what the Cosmos said they wanted to do last summer, but it's actually been working in the case of Red Bull New York. Albeit with more global resources and experience available thanks to the club being part of multi-club apparatus Red Bull GmbH.

With a first year head coach in Michael Bradley, who made the jump after leading the organization's reserve team to a league title in MLS Next Pro, the point was made even more obvious. The development with RBNY of players like Julian Hall, Adri Mehmeti, and Ronald Donkor should have positive impacts on their future careers. Those careers just probably won't be continuing in Harrison, NJ, for too much longer, and that's the hard part.

While embracing youth and bringing along top talents like Hall and Mehmeti, who are already breaking through with the United States men's national team while teenagers, the Red Bulls have missed the playoffs in back-to-back seasons. It's the first time ever in the franchise's history that they've missed the MLS Cup Playoffs in back-to-back years, and it's after they'd enjoyed a 15-year streak of qualifying for the playoffs that got snapped in 2025.

RBNY was just reaching its competitive peak when GTA V arrived in September 2013, but the positive momentum is missing here in 2026 as you spend the rest of your week/weekend/year playing GTA VI.

Comments

Latest

NYCFC attendance rose slightly during the 2026 season

NYCFC attendance rose slightly during the 2026 season

Year-over-year home attendance increased by 3.6% for New York City FC in 2026, buoyed by the second-biggest home crowd in club history turning out to see Lionel Messi in March, with 2026 representing NYCFC's best overall and average attendance numbers since the 2018 season.

Members Public