The Major League Soccer Players Association today released one final round of player salary updates before 2026 comes to a close.
This follows up on the salary data shared by the MLSPA back in May, which we wrote up here at the time. All the NYCFC salary data below is as of October 9, 2026, meaning it was compiled before NYCFC announced its end-of-season roster decisions.
For that reason, a bunch of players who are no longer under contract with NYCFC appear on this salary list. We've accounted for that in the table collecting all the salary numbers below by putting the players without contracts for 2027 in italics. We also put an asterisk next to the names of those currently not with NYCFC because they've been loaned out to other clubs.
That's a three-player list, Jovan Mijatović, Julián Fernández, and Seymour Reid — though it's unclear how much, if any, of their 2026 compensation gets covered by the teams that picked them up on loan. It's also unclear why Reid is not included in NYCFC's list of salaried players as released by the MLSPA, since he's still a NYCFC player away on loan, the same status of Mijatović and Julián Fernández. He's included here, giving us 38 players, and their guaranteed 2026 compensation, to consider.
Also, you should remember that Matt Miazga — listed below as earning $1.64 million in compensation in 2026 — was waived and bought out of his contract by his previous club, FC Cincinnati, so there's zero chance NYCFC paid anywhere near that high of a salary figure to employ Miazga for three months as a training player. This MLSPA update doesn't differentiate between his guaranteed Cincinnati earnings and whatever prorated salary NYCFC paid him during that brief time in New York.
Anyway, on to the salary numbers, followed by a few key takeaways after looking through all this compensation data.
NYCFC salaries, sorted by guaranteed '26 compensation
| Name | Guaranteed Comp |
|---|---|
| Nico Fernández Mercau | $3,650,000.00 |
| Bénie Traoré | $2,509,001.00 |
| Thiago Martins | $2,262,000.00 |
| Matt Miazga | $1,639,000.00 |
| Hannes Wolf | $1,510,000.00 |
| Talles Magno | $1,365,000.00 |
| James Sands | $1,274,083.33 |
| Keaton Parks | $1,130,000.00 |
| Alonso Martínez | $850,333.33 |
| Matt Freese | $795,833.33 |
| Raul Gustavo | $792,560.00 |
| Julián Fernández* | $784,300.00 |
| Andrés Perea | $776,625.00 |
| Jovan Mijatović* | $737,500.00 |
| Luighi | $664,540.00 |
| Tayvon Gray | $660,437.50 |
| Aiden O'Neill | $630,937.50 |
| Agustín Ojeda | $607,833.33 |
| Maxi Moralez | $500,000.00 |
| Mitja Ilenič | $391,700.00 |
| Kevin O'Toole | $338,000.00 |
| Kai Trewin | $311,541.68 |
| Maximo Carrizo | $194,236.74 |
| Tomás Romero | $163,668.75 |
| Jacob Arroyave | $126,397.50 |
| Jonny Shore | $125,900.00 |
| Drew Baiera | $119,335.50 |
| Nico Cavallo | $115,247.59 |
| Greg Ranjitsingh | $113,400.00 |
| Malachi Jones | $113,400.00 |
| Seymour Reid* | $104,937.92 |
| Peter Molinari | $95,674.70 |
| Kevin Pierre | $90,225.63 |
| Max Murray | $89,872.59 |
| Cooper Flax | $88,025.00 |
| Kamran Acito | $88,025.00 |
| Arnau Farnós | $88,025.00 |
| Mac Learned | $88,025.00 |
Player no longer on NYCFC's roster
*Player is off NYCFC's roster while on loan
1. Millions coming off the books
If NYCFC fully parts ways with all 11 players who are listed on this salary report but who don't have contracts with the club beyond 2026, that would free up $7.03 million in salary dollars.
That number is inflated by counting Miazga at his full 2026 salary charge, but even with Miazga out of the equation, millions of dollars in salary have still been removed from NYCFC's books because of the decisions to move on from two high-earning veteran players, Thiago Martins ($2.26M) and Keaton Parks ($1.13M), as well as due to the uncertainty around possible returns of other mid-tier earners like Luighi ($664,540) and Maxi Moralez ($500,000).
Sporting director Todd Dunivant should have plenty of dollars to play with just in pure salary terms, never mind the general allocation money or target allocation money he could utilize with while trying to improve his roster heading into next season.
Some of that might go to players like Luighi and Moralez, who are each said to still be in talks with NYCFC about potential returns next season. Still, for now, there's lots of financial flexibility at the disposal of the NYCFC sporting director.

2. Bénie Traoré: Two goals for $2.5 million
For NYCFC purposes, the biggest point of interest of this salary dump was always going to be finding out exactly how much the club is paying its newest Designated Player, forward Bénie Traoré. His guaranteed compensation for 2026 came in at $2,509,001, making Traoré the second-highest paid NYCFC player behind fellow DP Nico Fernández Mercau ($3.65M).
Traoré had a rough first go-round in MLS this summer, ending his inaugural season with New York City FC with only two goals and one assist in 19 appearances made during the regular season. That translates to $836,333 spent per goal contribution from Traoré, or more brutally, $1.25 million per goal scored. He did at least end his 2026 season strong with one goal and one assist across his final three appearances of the season, but in 2027, NYCFC will need to get way more production out of their 23-year-old forward if he's going to justify the big transfer fee (rumored to be around €9 million) and salary.
3. No bang for NYCFC's buck in 2026
One of our fellow independent MLS outlets, SixOneFive Soccer which primarily covers Nashville SC, built the best interactive tool in the game for sifting through all the available MLS salary data. You should check it out and poke around as much as you'd like to see the MLS salary landscape in finer detail.

One thing you'll notice from SixOneFive's tool is that it lets you sort all the MLS teams by their dollars spent-to-points gained ratio this season. This metric is not a pretty one for New York City FC, as the club spent $616,000 per point, with the team's $25,880,685 total player compensation spend only yielding 42 points and an 11th-place finish in the Eastern Conference.
That was the sixth highest dollar spend per point gained in MLS this season. While it's not quite as bad as Atlanta United FC, which spent $1.16 million per point en route to finishing 13th in the East, that's not the kind of company NYCFC is trying to keep.
The $25,880,685 figure, the total guaranteed compensation paid by NYCFC to its players in 2026, ranks the club ninth out of the 30 MLS teams, so you can't say that NYCFC hasn't been spending. This season, though, the sizable salary outlays did not translate to on-field production.
4. Most expensive player feels like a bargain
Nicolás Fernández Mercau still leads the way as NYCFC's highest-earning player, but his price point feels downright reasonable given the 2026 season he just wrapped up. Fernández Mercau's $3.65 million in guaranteed compensation ranks 37th among all MLS players, and in a season that saw the Argentine score 16 goals and add six assists. The 22 goal contributions this season put him among the top 10 of all MLS players, so the production well outpaced the pay.
Fernández Mercau is the highest-earning NYCFC player since back when David Villa pulled in $5.61 million in compensation during the 2018 season, and since arriving during the summer of 2025, Nico has lived up to that high cost.
5. Changes for those on new contracts
A group of squad members got new contracts from the club this season: James Sands, Kevin O'Toole, Tayvon Gray, Tomás Romero, and Greg Ranjitsingh all signed midseason contract extensions to lengthen their stays in New York City.
None of these new deals translated to significant in-season changes to the compensation owed to any of that group of players. Ranjitsingh's compensation remained exactly the same, Sands and Gray's compensation went down ever so slightly compared to what they were owed as of the May salary report, and Romero and O'Toole got minor bumps up in pay.
| Name | Comp (May '26) | Comp (Nov '26) | $ Change |
|---|---|---|---|
| James Sands | $1,318,750 | $1,274,083.33 | -$44,666.67 |
| Tayvon Gray | $664,000 | $660,437.50 | -$3,562.50 |
| Kevin O'Toole | $323,333 | $338,000.00 | $14,667.00 |
| Tomás Romero | $113,400 | $163,668.75 | $50,268.75 |
| Greg Ranjitsingh | $113,400 | $113,400.00 | $0 |
Future seasons to come might see each player's compensation number change more significantly, but for now, locking this group up on longer deals didn't cost NYCFC much more in salary dollars during the 2026 season.

