Earlier this month, Italian outlet La Gazetta dello Sport reported that City Football Group, owners of New York City FC, expressed interest in AC Milan forward and United States men's national team star Christian Pulisic.
The report from Filippo Conticello claims that CFG wants to make Pulisic the "symbol of New York City FC" with the Pigeons' new soccer-specific home opening in Queens next summer.
While a move for the 87-time capped USMNT international seems unlikely this summer, sources told the New York Soccer Journal that Pulisic has rejected AC Milan's latest contract offer. Rumored to be worth in the region of $5 million per season, reports later emerged, once again from La Gazetta dello Sport, of a contract offer made from New York City FC worth double that, a whopping $10 million per season.
AC Milan owner Gerry Cardinale has been adamant regarding Pulisic's future, considering the American the "star of the team" and a core part of his Milan squad. That said, there's been no public comment from Pulisic or his camp, with the American currently leading the USMNT into the knockout stages of the 2026 FIFA World Cup.
Notable American talent continues to get lured back to Major League Soccer. Just this year saw forward Josh Sargent made the switch from Norwich City to Toronto FC for $22 million in January. The year prior saw USMNT goalkeeper Matt Turner returning to New England Revolution on loan from Olympic Lyonnais and USMNT midfielder Paxten Aaronson move to the Colorado Rapids in a $4 million deal from Eintracht Frankfurt last August.
Christian Pulisic is on another level than those aforementioned USMNT teammates, someone who won UEFA Champions League with Chelsea FC and with successful years at both Milan and Borussia Dortmund sandwiching his time in London.
Would he really trade spending his remaining under-30 prime years in Europe for more time spent playing in front of US soccer fans back home in the States? New York City is a massive market, and New York City FC is offering Pulisic an enticing salary and the opportunity to become the face of both a marquee franchise and the top league in his home nation.
It remains to be seen how interested Pulisic might be in making this move, but what can be discussed is the impact signing Pulisic would have on New York City FC and on the wider league as a whole.
This post is free to all readers. Consider becoming a paid subscriber to support our continued coverage.
Etihad Park is scheduled to open during the summer of 2027, and it will mark the beginning of New York City FC's next chapter of existence. For years, the club has avoided the allure of superstar-caliber Designated Players, and many have blamed the baseball stadiums NYCFC calls home, Yankee Stadium and Citi Field.
The idea that players like Lionel Messi, Antoine Griezmann, or Son Heung-Min would choose not to bring their talents to the Big Apple due to the lack of true soccer-specific facilities for home matches has lingered, but in 2027, that excuse ends.
Christian Pulisic is the exact kind of statement signing clubs make when looking to signal the start of a new era in their history. Pulisic is the most successful American soccer player of all time, with trophies littered across a European career crossing England, Germany, and Italy. He's the most valuable American footballer in history, sold to Chelsea for $73 million. All of this contributed to his ever-growing brand getting established as the most recognizable current symbol of American soccer.
His presence with New York City FC would draw interest from soccer fans all across the United States, similar to the allure of seeing a Messi or Son with their respective clubs. Etihad Park's 25,000-seat capacity would be met every week, and away matches would be full of fans looking to watch an American soccer icon play in their home city.
From a marketing perspective, there is no bigger player to draw in the casual American soccer fan that isn't named Messi, Ronaldo, or Mbappé. Signing Pulisic to a long-term deal would put New York City FC back into the top end of MLS jersey sales and would boost their revenue in ways not seen since the long-gone days of the "big three" Designated Players signed for the inaugural 2015 season.
Not only that, but the signing of Pulisic would be a statement on multiple levels. On one hand, the move would signal to the rest of the league that New York City FC is serious about competing for MLS Cup glory and wants to be a dominant team in the Eastern Conference.
It would also be a statement from MLS to the rest of the world that they, too, are a top global league that can attract world-class players still at the peak of their powers. Let's not forget that Pulisic has the third-most goal contributions of any player in Serie A since 2023, with 52 G/A in 100 games, the most of any player at AC Milan in that span.
Pulisic is only 27 years old. He's entering the prime years of his career, having already tasted winning silverware at the highest levels of club football. He is a player who can still very well make a move to a top-tier European side before he exits his prime. This fact alone makes the job of convincing the Hershey, Pennsylvania native to return to the United States difficult. That's why CFG is reportedly offering to double his salary with their first offer.
Working with AC Milan looks like it will be tricky, given the owner's insistence that Pulisic not be sold. New York City FC is also doing business elsewhere, reportedly adding Ivory Coast forward Bénie Traoré, who would join as a possible club-record Designated Player signing. The club does not have a history of opening the wallet and spending record sums of cash on two players in one summer.
A deal for Pulisic before his Milan contract expires would likely require a huge transfer fee, one that might shatter both the NYCFC and MLS incoming transfer records by a multi-million dollar margin. Is that kind of move a bit of a fantasy at this moment? Yes. But would the investment in Pulisic, and his presumed impact both on and off the pitch, be worth it? Yes, emphatically yes.
Pulisic's ability alone would make his signing worthwhile, but the bonus of his marketability and status as one of America's domestic sporting icons would do leaps and bounds for New York City FC and MLS, as the league would bank on another uptick in viewership, and the Pigeons would get the star they've longed for to compete for a second MLS Cup.
It's a move that, on paper, makes perfect sense for New York City FC and City Football Group, and in time, maybe Christian Pulisic, too. Right now, the odds of this Galactico-style transfer hitting the Big Apple are slim, but worth keeping an eye on as we draw closer to the grand opening of New York City FC's new soccer-specific home next year.
