Skip to content
MLS

The last MLS Cup Playoffs before the real weirdness begins

The 2026 MLS Cup Playoffs will provide a last sense of normalcy before MLS embarks on its next era of playoff format reinvention.

From a past MLS Cup lift in 2022. Photo via Getty

Antoine Griezmann, newly-minted 2026 MLS Newcomer of the Year of newly-eliminated Orlando City SC, holds the same philosophy as the New York Soccer Journal: While the one-and-done Wild Card matches are billed as playoff games, the MLS Cup Playoffs don't really start until the best-of-three Round One, which kicks off today with a three-match slate.

Now it's down to a 16-team field, though it could take as many as 11 more days to get from 16 to eight teams and the Conference Semifinals, depending on how many Round One series require decisive third games.

Even in its fourth year, the best-of-three round still has some oddness about it. It takes too long, and many of the Round One games lack the sense of urgency that accompanies a win-or-go-home knockout match. It may be more "fair" than single-elimination playoff rounds in that teams to lose Game One of Round One get a second shot at playoff life, but it also drags the playoff schedule on and elongates the time between the regular season ending and the playoff champion being crowned. It's also goofy enough, with penalty kicks a factor to decide each game of the series, so as to require teams like New England Revolution to post explainer infographics on their social media accounts so fans understand what they're getting into.

The best-of-three complaints are real and have been consistent since its introducuction in 2023, but this also could very well be the last time we ever see this style of playoff series in MLS.

The sprint season's playoffs are guaranteed to be different, and MLS is reportedly introducing a whole new playoff format when the league "relaunches" in July 2027 with its flipped competitive calendar.

After the 2026 MLS Cup gets handed out on December 18, the 2027 sprint season comes next in February, and that streamlined mini-season will have appropriately streamlined playoffs to accompany it.

The sprint season actually brings back a playoff format preferred by many: Single-elimination only, eight teams from each conference. That was the setup after MLS ditched two-legged ties beginning with the 2019 season, but it only lasted four seasons: Exactly as many seasons as the best-of-three Round One lasted.

MLS loves messing with its playoff format and does it frequently, something well covered by New York Soccer Journal's The Blueprint podcast in early September. The planned playoff format that might come after the sprint season — first reported by The Guardian in August — is said to include 20 teams with play-in rounds, double-elimination opportunities for top seeds, and other tweaks like using a single table, not geographic conferences, to determine who gets in and who gets left out.

The Blueprint: Is there an ideal MLS playoff format?
A walk through the history of the many different MLS Cup Playoff formats used over the years sheds a different light on the proposed new version the league is weighing introducing for the 2027/28 season.

This 2026 tournament is a real last hurrah before MLS embarks on its next era of playoff, and calendar, reinvention.

The sprint season playoffs will give everyone a taste of the playoff life MLS led between 2019 and 2022, but that tournament will feel strange in its own unique way, since the field of 16 playoff teams to compete in that 2027 tournament will only have played 14 regular-season matches prior to the playoffs. The concept of crowning a MLS Cup champion off the back of 14 regular season games plus four more playoff victories, and having that team join the list of 31 others to lift the trophy in league history, still doesn't sit quite right.

The format that arrives in 2027/28 seems set to ditch the best-of-three and rely more on single-elimination games, but while adding all kinds of other quirks to the system. The plan, to somewhat mirror the playoffs used in Australian rules football, would be a serious departure from what MLS, and what fans of other professional American sports, are accustomed to seeing after the regular season ends.

For now, the 2026 MLS Cup Playoffs will provide a last sense of normalcy before MLS gets progressively weirder with it over the next two seasons. These playoffs will be defined by whether or not the league's best-ever regular season team, Nashville SC and its points-record-setting Supporters' Shield season, can back that success up through each postseason round en route to a double. That's a pretty normal conversation to be had around MLS playoff time, since the Supporters' Shield winner has a tendency to get knocked out of the playoffs, only winning both Shield and Cup eight times.

The Opta supercomputer actually thinks Nashville's foil in the Western Conference, the first-place Vancouver Whitecaps, are more likely to be the team lifting MLS Cup on that Friday night in mid-December.

The five MLS Cup favorites, via Opta.

The playoff path is never easy for a top-ranked team, and maybe the new system on the horizon to decide the 2027/28 season will change the calculus for an overall No 1 seed, given the system will reportedly provide extra advantages like being able to win one game and advance straight to the quarterfinals, while your lower-seeded competitors battle it out with more matches to play to reach the same stage.

That new system and all its nuances still have to be confirmed by the league and implemented. For now, it's one last relatively normal round of playoffs to crown the 2026 MLS Cup winner. Fill out your brackets wisely.

Comments

Latest

NYCFC attendance rose slightly during the 2026 season

NYCFC attendance rose slightly during the 2026 season

Year-over-year home attendance increased by 3.6% for New York City FC in 2026, buoyed by the second-biggest home crowd in club history turning out to see Lionel Messi in March, with 2026 representing NYCFC's best overall and average attendance numbers since the 2018 season.

Members Public